When is Truth no longer true?


Have you ever seen a house built out of cards? They’re amazing! I did a Google search to try to find a picture of one, and I found the Web site of the guy who holds the world record in building card houses. His record? Over 25 feet high. The thing is, I think the UPC’s record beats his by a few hundred feet. Why? Because the UPC’s theology is nothing more than a house built out of cards.

I mean, look at this picture:


You’ve got to admit that this guy is nothing short of amazing (check out his Web site for more pictures).

But now I want you to imagine something. Imagine that Felix the wonder kitten comes into the room and decides to scratch his back on the card house. Imagine that wonder kitty knocks out one of the four columns that the house stands on. What do you think would happen?

Well, from the look of the picture, the whole thing would collapse. But let’s say it doesn’t. Let’s say that it still manages to stand…except now it’s really tilted and unstable.

A few minutes pass, and then Felix the wonder kitten decides to sharpen his claws on the table that the house of cards is standing on. Now he takes out column number 2! And what happens? Well…Felix the wonder cat has just now used up one of his nine lives because he just got crushed by a massive amount of cards.

See, that’s the problem with a house of cards. It’s inherently unstable. It looks really, really nice, but if a strong wind (or an inquisitive cat) comes along and knocks just a few of the cards out then it’s no longer a house of cards. It’s then a pile of cards!

And that’s the problem with the UPC belief system. I am convinced that it is nothing more than a house of cards.

Here’s what I mean: The UPC has a fairly unique idea of truth. They believe that they alone possess truth, and that everyone else is wrong. The reason that this is unique is because most Christian denominations are more than willing to admit that they could be wrong about something. That’s why most denominations have a statement of faith that covers the things that they think are really important (usually things such as the virgin birth, the physical death, burial, and resurrection of Christ, the inerrancy of Scripture, etc.), but then they recognize that there are plenty of other things that the Bible just doesn’t make clear.

Well, the UPC doesn’t take that stance. The UPC believes that it’s right, and that’s that. There’s very, very little room for debate. The UPC’s mentality works like this:

– We have truth
– Therefore we are right

If anyone questions why they have truth then they claim it’s because they have the Holy Ghost. Of course, what they really mean is that they speak in tongues, but that’s a separate issue.

Anyway, here’s the point: The UPC has built a house of cards. They have told their people that they are completely, 100%, totally right about everything. No room for doubting, no room for error, the UPC is right.

But then…what happens when the UPC is wrong?

Take make-up for instance. I am firmly convinced that a person simply cannot make a Biblical case for make-up being a sin. You just can’t do it. Why? Because it’s not in the Bible! There are three Scriptures—three!—that even mention make-up, and they don’t have anything bad to say about it! Yet the UPC claims that it is wrong for a woman to wear make-up.

And what about pants? More and more UPCers are admitting to me that they see nothing wrong with a woman wearing pants. But here’s the problem: The reason that they continue to refuse to wear pants is because they say that they “have the Truth”!

The same goes for make-up, jewelry, and a host of other issues that more and more UPCers are seeing are not based on sound Biblical exegesis [interpretation].

Think about that for a moment.

So where am I going with all of this? Well, I’ll tell ya’ :)

What’s happening is that more and more cards are being pulled out of the UPC’s theological house. Beliefs about make-up are going, jewelry is going, TVs are long gone, pants are mostly gone (show me a UPC woman who doesn’t wear pajama pants and I’ll show you a rare UPC woman). But yet many people in the UPC are still convinced that Jesus’ Name baptism and speaking in tongues are necessary for salvation, so they continue to adhere to things that they no longer believe. Why? Because they are convinced that they “have the Truth.”

So my question to them is this: When is Truth no longer true?

In other words, how many cards do we have to pull out before we realize that our house of cards is no longer a house? How many beliefs do we have to recognize are wrong before we recognize that there’s something wrong with the whole system?

It was the realization that the UPC’s belief system is a house of cards that was one of the main factors in my decision to leave. At some point in 2006 I realized that there was no way the UPC could have a “special revelation” from God and still hold to so many biblically unfounded beliefs.

I simply realized that Truth has to be true. If the UPC “has Truth” or is “in the Truth” then what it teaches will be, well, true! On the other hand, if even one of the UPC’s cardinal teachings is found to be incorrect then that brings the whole system under fire. It doesn’t necessarily mean that it’s all wrong, but it does mean that a person should seriously examine it to find out what else is wrong with system.


I think that many people have already recognized that certain UPC doctrines are wrong. I encourage those people to examine the rest of what the UPC teaches to find out whether or not it’s correct. After all, it’s God’s Word that will judge us, not a denomination’s statement of faith.

Finally, I had two different UPC friends make this statement to me when we were talking about fallacies in the UPC’s beliefs: “Don’t throw out the baby with the bath water.” They both admitted that there were many things that the UPC teaches that they don’t believe, but they still believe the “main doctrines” (I.e., tongues, baptism, and hair for these two people), so they warned me to “not throw out the baby with the bath water.”

Here was my response to them: “There is no baby!”

Too many cards are gone. The house has collapsed. I am convinced that the UPC doesn’t have a leg to stand on. Therefore, when I left I didn’t throw out the baby with the bath water…I just walked away from a pile of cards that collapsed a long time ago.


5 thoughts on “When is Truth no longer true?

  1. Phil

    Admin edit: Post removed. Phil, if you would like to re-post the same thoughts without accusing fellow Christians of worshiping evil spirits in place of the Holy Spirit, not having true faith, having uncircumcised hearts, and being filled with sin, then I’m sure we’d all love to hear your thoughts. However, inflammatory posts like the one you made are not welcome here.

    In Christ,
    Josh S.

  2. Jess

    Reading this, and the following comments gives me hope. This summer I have become very good friends with a couple people who are involved in and were raised in a UPC/Apostolic church. I’ve been discouraged and hurt by the fact that they see me as unsaved because I grew up in a Christian Reformed church and now attend a Baptist church. I keep praying for them and sharing my testimony because I feel God has put me in their life for a reason. I keep praying that he will open their eyes to the truth and use me in whatever way he wills. There are many times when I am tempted to give up because I feel they have been so indoctrinated that they will never really listen to what I’m saying. Hearing from people who were in the UPC church and who were able to break away from it gives me hope. Ultimately I know that it is God who will change their heart, but reading this and the comments with it were definately and encouragement.

  3. Karen

    What a joy to know I am not alone and I was only exposed for 8 months. But because I was not only searching to know Jesus I was also searching for a “family.” I was drawn into the fellowship the moment I stepped foot in the Apostolic-faith church here in southern Maine. The pastor, a very handsome charismatic man “had me at hello (the words from the movie Jerry McGuire).” Leaving was painful because I wanted to remain with these folks. I sent article after article with scripture hoping to change the pastor’s beliefs about speaking in tongues (as step one) so I could remain. When I had this revelation I said WHOA sister. This isn’t about you. So I apologized, wished them well and quit all contact. I was immediately set free although I still miss them.

    Truth really does set us free! Praise God for His wisdom to shine upon those who will listen.

  4. Charles Buchanan

    Ive been away from the upc for about 7 months and i feel so great! I had been praying for guidance and the hand of God to lead me into faith. I came to my senses when my father died in 07, the pastor of the church came to the hospice and I was crushed because I thought he was surely in hell. Because He hadnt been baptized in Jesus name or spoke in tongues but he was a awesome guy, that loved and gave. to make a long story short I was in tears I told this pastor my fears about my dad and he told me well remember the thief on the cross God can do what he wants. What i thought just last sunday you said if we arent baptized in Jesus name and have spoken in tongues we are not saved! From that moment on I no longer believed a thing he told me and began my search for faith in God. It took me 3 more years to get away from that place. I feel like I have been in hell for most of my life because of the lies I was taught. Now I am free, Im not perfect but free!

  5. Em

    I don’t know who you are but PRAISE GOD!!! I could not believe it when I read about the cards!! WOW that is amazing. I have been looking for an explanation like this for years. I left 2 years ago and I wept and didn’t know how to stand on my own untill I pressed on and the Lord heard my cry. I was under a grip/stronghold of the upci in colorado that I went to for 15 years. No more. The Lord set me free. I found a church that has ballance and I am free from that bondage I dove into. I don’t know why I gave so much to them just to be chewed up and spit out. The Lord told me that It was HE whom I must Follow. I do. God Bless you. You’d be surprised with how many people out here in colorado are surching for a way out. So many I know are still in it because they say there is no where to go otherwise they would of been gone years ago. How sad.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *